A picture of Senator Harry Reid
Harry R.
Democrat NV

About Sen. Harry
  • Insular Areas and Freely Associated States Energy Development—Continued

    by Senator Harry Reid

    Posted on 2014-12-13

    submit to reddit

    Read More about Insular Areas and Freely Associated States Energy Development-- Continued

    REID. Mr. President, the junior Senator from Texas raises a point of order attacking the pending legislation on the grounds that the President has acted unconstitutionally. The junior Senator from Texas is wrong, wrong, wrong on several counts. But most importantly for us this evening, it is an attack on this bill because this is not an appropriate place to debate the constitutionality of any executive branch action. Under the precedents of the Senate, the Senate determines whether it is constitutional to consider the legislation before it.



    The House of Representatives passed this legislation before us in an exercise of its powers under article I of the United States Constitution. This bill has, thus, originated in the House within the meaning of the origination clause of the Constitution.

    Voting on this measure is no different from thousands of other measures on which the Senate has voted. The Constitution objection is completely--completely--without merit and should be rejected.

    The PRESIDENT pro tempore. Who yields time? Mr. REID. Mr. President, I yield back all time.

    The PRESIDENT pro tempore. All time has expired.

    Mr. REID. Mr. President, regular order.

    The PRESIDENT pro tempore. All time has expired. Regular order has been requested.

    Under the precedents and practices of the Senate, the Chair has no power or authority to pass on such a point of order. The Chair, therefore, under the precedents of the Senate, submits the question to the Senate, Is the point of order well taken? The yeas and nays were previously ordered.

    The clerk will call the roll.

    The legislative clerk called the roll.

  • submit to reddit
  • Register your constituent account to respond

    Constituent Register